Grieving Someone Who Is Still Alive: Grief After a Breakup or Estrangement

 

Grieving someone who is still alive is real grief. When a relationship ends through a breakup, an estrangement or the loss of a friendship, we may experience what is known as ambiguous loss: a loss without the clarity or closure that might help us move through it. This grief can also be disenfranchised, meaning it isn't always recognized or supported by the people around us. This post explores what happens when we avoid grief, why it can get stuck, and what can open up when we let ourselves feel it gradually and with support. I am an emotion-focused therapist in Toronto, and I work with grief and relationship loss through individual relationship counselling, virtually across Ontario.

Grief in Fall: Harvest and Loss

It’s early Fall here in Toronto (at least as I begin to write:). The weather is gorgeous, the cool breeze a respite from summer humidity. The sun is a golden blanket that warms to the touch but doesn’t overwhelm. The gardens are mature. Ripe. And yet, we know what’s coming. Soon, the leaves will change colour, in a rainbow display, and then fall.

Fall evokes a mix of abundance and loss, a bittersweetness; peak harvest meets an ending, loss of a precious and finite Canadian summer, with its adventures and possibilities.

I’d like to use this as a way to teach about grief, and about the seeds that processing our grief can plant inside of us.

Many clients come to me because an important relationship has ended. Often it’s a romantic relationship, but sometimes it’s a friendship. Or estrangement from family. Because the loss of someone who is still alive isn’t communally acknowledged or ritualized in the way a death is, it is sometimes called disenfranchised grief.

As the seasons turn, how do we both appreciate and even revel in the blessings we still have, while carving out all the space we need to grieve our losses?

Entering the Waters: How to Start Grieving Safely

leaves floating on the water

When we lose someone we have held dear, whether through a breakup, an estrangement or a death, our grief can feel like the undertow of an ocean, whose waters threaten to pull us under, to drown us. It can be scary, overwhelming, or just unappealing to learn how to safely navigate these wild waters so that we can, over time, digest the reality of our losses. It makes total sense that most of us have parts that avoid our own feelings of grief like the plague. It’s about psychological survival!

But that is what’s needed. To spend some time, some of the time, learning how to surf the waves of our losses. So that we can digest the reality of our experiences, and be in touch with what is moving inside of us, in real time. So that we can, slowly, over time, expand large enough to bear our losses and keep living.

We don’t need to constantly be in a grief-processing state. It’s important to recognize when we are tired, and choose to rest, to lie on the metaphoric sand for a while. Moreover, it’s necessary to choose the life we still have to live - and to continue to love, laugh, live, work, and play while we’re in a grieving process.

But it is critical, when we are actively grieving, to find safe containers to experience and express our grief. This can manifest in diverse ways. You may choose a ritual - like spending time outside, with a hot beverage, and letting yourself feel for a finite amount of time. You may dance so that the feelings move, confide in a safe friend, write in a journal, take in one of the myriad art forms expressing heartache.

The Cost of Avoiding Grief: When Grief Stays Unresolved

When we rigidly avoid our grief, and never let ourselves feel it, our grieving process can get stuck. We get emotionally constipated. This can cause a host of problems. Grief and chronic emotional distress can also affect us physically, sometimes showing up in sleep, digestion, tension, or other bodily symptoms.

And our avoidance can take up more and more space - maybe through overworking, overconsuming substances or social media, etc. Our life can easily become about avoidance. We’re shut down, not fully alive, not totally conscious.

And when our grief never gets digested, it remains unresolved. Unprocessed grief can easily take the driver's seat of our lives, unconsciously driving our decisions and taking us farther away from our authentic selves and our life paths.

What Grief Might Give Us: What Can Grow After Loss

When we brave facing the wildness of our sorrow, we can let the dark magic of grief soften us. Let it break open our hearts so that we have more compassion for ourselves, for others.

Admittedly, it’s a tough sell. Fully feeling our grief is painful, and the benefits are a bit mysterious. Potentially transformative, yes, but not under our control. Processing grief does seem to deepen us, though. Many an artist was born through loss. Many a healer was birthed through processing and integrating their wounding.

Grief is Alive. It is Wild. In the words of psychotherapist Francis Weller, “Grief is not a problem to be solved, not a condition to be medicated, but a deep encounter with the essential experience of being human.” A big part of living is learning how to lose with grace. Because everything and everyone we love, we will eventually lose. And if we refuse to allow the mystery of grief to work on us, we stay closed off from life, from new experiences of love and beauty that could expand us.

When We Get Stuck: Grieving Someone Who Is Still Alive

Some emotional processes that resemble grieving can actually keep us from moving through the grief. Overly harsh self-criticism, guilt, self-blame. Spending excessive and obsessive mental energy trying to figure out the other person - how they feel, how they could have done this, why they didn’t stay. While some of this may be necessary, since we don’t have access to the inner world of the person who has left us, grieving often involves surrendering to uncertainty. Closure often has to become an internal process.  

Relatedly, when a person is still alive but the relationship is over or limited, the lack of a final ending can make it harder to move through. Hope can stay alive longer than is helpful. Reunion remains technically possible, however unlikely, which can keep us hooked. This is part of the complexity of ambiguous, non-death relationship losses, and why they can take time to move through. 

As an emotion-focused therapist, I guide people through their avoidance or fear of grief, through overly self-critical processes, too much regret, or too much focus on the what-ifs, the whys, the “what are they thinking now?” - and back to the heart of the matter. The raw pain of losing the relationship we want with someone we love.

If This Resonates

If you are carrying a loss that feels stuck, know that you are not alone in it. Many people who come to therapy with me are grieving a breakup, a friendship, an estrangement, or a death, and are finding it hard to find their way through.

This is often part of the work in individual relationship counselling, where I support you to feel your way through your pain at your pace. Together we explore what is moving inside you, including through emotion-focused therapy. If you would like, you can schedule a no-cost video consultation to see whether my approach is a match for your goals.

Letting Go Without Erasing Love: How to Let Go of Someone You Love After a Breakup

Over time, over a process that is often longer than we anticipated, my clients show me how beautiful it can be to let the current and future relationship go, to slowly and gently and nonlinearly accept that the chapter has ended, while allowing the love to remain a part of our story.

single green leaf on a pile of brown dead leaves

As Esther Perel, relationship expert, teaches, some relationships are Love Stories, some are Life Stories. And some cannot occupy center stage in the way we would like, but can still live somewhere in the auditorium of our lives. There are some people we need to no longer have in our lives at all, and some who we may choose to learn to co-exist with, but with boundaries.

It is human to cling to love. With all our might. But regardless of our determination, the other can slip away all the same. Hopefully, we will love again. But we may not get to love that special someone or someones, not in the same way, not in real life. How do we hold the lost love in our hearts, claim it, without getting stuck, while also accepting the reality of loss?

This, I believe, is the art of grief work. The both/and - of loving and losing. Over time, allowing our tears to gently and nonlinearly weaken the glue that holds us to our former beloveds, so that we can have more space to live and connect in the present. And, somehow, not throwing away the love entirely. Still holding the loving feelings in our hearts, if they are indeed there.

Healing After Loss: Holding the Bitter and the Sweet

One beautiful outcome of a grieving process that has been given time and space is that we can hold the bitter and the sweet. We can feel the gentle sadness of missing, without feeling overly pulled away from the current of our present lives. We can let in the history of being loved and loving, without the feelings of inadequacy or regret that a breakup or relationship loss can leave.

It’s messy, wild, and beautiful territory. And I feel honored to be able to guide clients through grief and relationship loss, so that they are able to fully experience it, and not be so alone in it. And when they get stuck in dead-ends, I have a map that I can use to guide them back to the heart of the matter.

women in jean jacket in the forest throwing leaves up in the air

A Closing Blessing

May this Fall remind us how beautiful it can be to let things go, and may your hearts be full, and even if they are breaking, may they break open, and may you feel held.

Aviva.

Start With a Conversation

If grief or relationship loss is weighing on you, I invite you to schedule a no-cost video consultation to explore whether my approach is a match for your therapy goals. Grief often asks us to be vulnerable in ways that can feel risky. If that sounds familiar, you may also relate to struggling with vulnerability. Grief can also leave us feeling very alone with it, and you may relate to loneliness and isolation.

Keep reading: Is It Safe to Trust Again? Navigating Trust After Hurt | Conflict Avoidance Isn’t Kindness: Reclaiming Your Voice in Relationships


Questions About Grief After a Breakup or Estrangement

Can you grieve a breakup or an estrangement, not only a death?

Yes. Grief follows the loss of anyone we have held dear, including a romantic partner, a friend, or a family member we are estranged from. Many people who come to therapy with me are grieving a relationship that has ended, which can involve a profound sense of loss, even though the person is still alive.

How do you grieve someone who is still alive?

When a breakup or estrangement involves a lack of clarity, closure or finality, the resulting loss may be understood as ambiguous loss, and the grief as ambiguous grief. Since the person is still alive, the ending may not feel final, and the possibility of reunion technically still exists. This grief may also be disenfranchised, meaning there may not be adequate recognition, ritual, or support from others. The work begins with letting the loss be real, and having a space to feel and express your grief gradually, with support.

What is ambiguous grief?

Ambiguous grief, also called ambiguous loss, is grief without a clear ending or closure. The term comes from Pauline Boss, who described losses where someone is gone in one way but still present in another. After a breakup or an estrangement, the person may be alive and out of reach, which can keep love, anger, hope and sadness tangled together.

How do you let go of someone you love without erasing the love?

Over time, and often longer than we expect, many people find they can accept that a chapter has ended while the love remains a part of their story. In my work this happens gently and nonlinearly, as tears loosen what holds us to a former beloved and make more room to live and connect in the present. And to find ways to cherish the love and the memories even as we continue to live and create new ones with others. 

Can therapy help with grief after a breakup or estrangement?

Many people who come to therapy with me are grieving a breakup, a friendship, an estrangement or a death, and we work with that loss as part of individual relationship counselling, virtually with adults across Ontario. You can schedule a no-cost 20-minute video consultation to see whether my approach feels like a match.

 

 
Aviva Belman

Aviva C. Bellman, MSW, RSW, is a Registered Social Worker and Psychotherapist in Toronto who has been in practice since 2018. She offers Emotion Focused Therapy to adults virtually across Ontario and has advanced training in EFT, including EFT for Couples. She is a member of the International Society for Emotion Focused Therapy.

Next
Next

Is It Safe to Trust Again? Navigating Trust After Hurt